Imagine having a surrogacy journey where your love story is celebrated, not questioned. For LGBTQ+ intended parents, finding the right surrogacy agency means more than just clinical expertise—it means working with professionals who understand your unique path to parenthood and have proven experience helping families like yours succeed.

While many surrogacy agencies claim to welcome all families, the reality is that experience with LGBTQ+ parents matters. The best gay surrogacy agency combines inclusive policies with specialized knowledge of the legal, medical, and emotional considerations that same-sex couples and transgender parents face.

We’ve evaluated agencies based on their track record with LGBT families, inclusive policies, and comprehensive support services to identify the five that truly excel in serving the LGBTQ+ community.

Ready to Start Your Family: Explore LGBTQ+-friendly surrogacy programs designed with your needs in mind.

Our  Agency Criteria

To identify the best surrogacy agencies for gay couples, we evaluated several key factors specific to LGBTQ+ family building:

• Experience working with LGBT parents and documented success rates
• Program emphasis on LGBT families and specialized services
• Inclusive policies including non-discrimination clauses and diverse representation
• Legal support for same-sex intended parents including parental rights expertise
• Counseling and psychological support tailored to LGBTQ+ experiences
• Location and state law compatibility for optimal legal protection
• Transparent cost structure and financing options

These criteria ensure agencies not only welcome LGBTQ+ families but have the expertise to navigate the specific challenges and opportunities that come with diverse family structures.

1. American Surrogacy: Best for Decades of LGBT Family-Building Experience

For over 30 years, American Surrogacy has been helping LGBTQ+ families grow through both surrogacy and adoption services via their sister agency, American Adoptions. This combined experience gives them unparalleled insight into the diverse paths LGBTQ+ parents take to build their families.

Summary: American Surrogacy’s decades of experience with LGBT families, combined with their comprehensive support network, makes them an industry leader for LGBTQ+ intended parents seeking proven expertise and inclusive care.

Key Advantages:

• 30+ years of combined experience in LGBT family building through surrogacy and adoption
• Specialized LGBT programs including tailored support for gay couples, lesbian couples, and transgender couples
• National reach with experience in all surrogacy-friendly states
• Comprehensive legal support with attorneys experienced in LGBTQ+ parental rights

Our Favorite Feature: Their dedicated LGBT family-building resources include separate programs specifically designed for gay men, lesbian couples, and transgender parents, ensuring personalized support for every family structure.

2. Brownstone Surrogacy: Best for Personalized Boutique Experience

Founded by attorney and gay father Jarret Zafran, Brownstone Surrogacy was literally built by someone who has walked in your shoes. After completing his own surrogacy journey, Zafran created the agency he wished had existed when he and his husband were building their family.

Summary: This New York-based boutique agency offers the personalized attention and LGBT-affirming approach that comes from being founded and operated by someone from the LGBTQ+ community.

Key Advantages:

• Gay father-founded agency with deep personal understanding of LGBTQ+ family building
• Licensed by New York State Department of Health, providing additional regulatory oversight
• Boutique approach ensures personalized attention and customized care
• Ethical transparency with clear, upfront pricing and no hidden fees

Considerations:

• Newer agency with smaller surrogate pool compared to larger national agencies
• Geographic focus may limit options for those preferring specific regions

Our Favorite Feature: Brownstone’s founder and director is available to personally guide clients through their journey, offering insights that only someone who has experienced surrogacy as a gay parent can provide.

3. Stronger Together Surrogacy: Best for Surrogate-Founded Advocacy

Founded by Ashley Cantrell, a five-time surrogate who completed her first journey for a same-sex couple, Stronger Together Surrogacy brings a unique perspective to LGBTQ+ family building. Having been on both sides of the surrogacy relationship, Ashley understands what makes matches successful.

Summary: This surrogate-founded agency combines advocacy-focused service with hands-on experience supporting LGBTQ+ families, creating a uniquely supportive environment for both intended parents and surrogates.

Key Advantages:

• Surrogate-founded leadership with personal experience carrying for same-sex couples
• Advocacy-focused approach that prioritizes both intended parents and surrogate welfare
• Community building that fosters long-term relationships between all parties
• Personalized matching based on values and compatibility beyond logistics

Considerations:

• Smaller scale may mean longer wait times for very specific preferences
• Newer agency still building national recognition

Our Favorite Feature: Ashley’s personal experience as a surrogate for same-sex couples informs every aspect of their matching process, ensuring both intended parents and surrogates feel supported and understood.

4. Growing Generations: Best for Egg and Sperm Donor Services

As one of the first agencies specifically created to serve gay men seeking parenthood, Growing Generations has nearly three decades of experience with LGBTQ+ families. They’ve pioneered many of the practices now considered standard in LGBT-inclusive surrogacy.

Summary: Growing Generations’ extensive experience and comprehensive donor services make them an excellent choice for LGBTQ+ parents who need both surrogacy and gamete donation services.

Key Advantages:

• Founded in 1996 specifically to help gay men become fathers
• Pioneering LGBT services including early support for HIV+ intended fathers
• Comprehensive donor programs for both egg and sperm donation
• Premium screening process with only top 2% of applicants becoming surrogates

Considerations:

• Premium positioning means higher costs than some alternatives
• Extensive screening process may extend initial matching timelines

Our Favorite Feature: Their historical focus on LGBTQ+ families means they’ve developed specialized protocols for unique situations, including helping HIV+ men become biological fathers—something few agencies offered when they pioneered this service.

5. Same Love Surrogacy: Best for LGBTQ+-Exclusive Specialization

Created by three gay fathers and a four-time surrogate who worked with international and domestic gay intended parents, Same Love Surrogacy focuses exclusively on serving the LGBTQ+ community with personalized, one-on-one guidance.

Summary: Same Love Surrogacy’s exclusive focus on LGBTQ+ families ensures every policy, procedure, and service is designed specifically for the unique needs of gay, lesbian, and transgender intended parents.

Key Advantages:

• LGBTQ+-exclusive focus ensures all services are tailored to community needs
• Founded by gay parents who understand the journey firsthand
• Personalized guidance with one-on-one counseling throughout the process
• Transparent approach with upfront, fully disclosed pricing

Considerations:

• Smaller client base may mean fewer surrogate options at any given time
• Exclusive focus may not suit those wanting broader agency experience

Our Favorite Feature: Their “we come to you” approach means they’ll meet with intended parents in their preferred location, recognizing that LGBTQ+ parents may prefer privacy during their initial consultations.

Why Working with a Gay-Friendly Surrogacy Agency Matters

What are the best surrogacy agencies for gay couples? The answer goes beyond basic non-discrimination policies. True LGBTQ+-friendly agencies understand the unique challenges same-sex couples face, from navigating varying state laws to addressing family dynamics that differ from traditional heterosexual partnerships.

Can same-sex couples use a surrogate in the U.S.? Absolutely, but success depends heavily on choosing the right agency and working in supportive states. The agencies listed here have experience navigating legal complexities and can guide you toward the most favorable jurisdictions for your family structure.

Key benefits of working with experienced LGBTQ+ surrogacy agencies include:

• Legal expertise in same-sex parental rights and varying state laws
• Cultural competency from teams who understand LGBTQ+ family dynamics
• Surrogate matching with carriers who actively welcome diverse families
• Specialized counseling addressing unique emotional aspects of LGBTQ+ surrogacy
• Network connections with LGBTQ+-friendly clinics, attorneys, and other professionals

Which states are best for LGBT surrogacy? Agencies with extensive LGBTQ+ experience can guide you toward states with the most favorable laws, including California, New York, Illinois, and others with explicit protections for same-sex intended parents.

Find an Agency Who Supports You In Every Way

What’s the best agency for two dads who want a baby? The answer depends on your specific needs, timeline, and preferences. Do surrogacy agencies accept LGBTQ+ parents? While most claim to, the agencies listed here go far beyond acceptance—they celebrate LGBTQ+ families and have proven track records of success.

Which surrogacy clinics are LGBT-friendly? The right agency will have established relationships with medical providers who not only accept LGBTQ+ patients but actively welcome and support diverse family structures. They can connect you with fertility clinics experienced in working with same-sex couples and transgender parents.

How do surrogacy agencies support transgender parents? Leading agencies offer specialized programs that understand the unique medical, legal, and emotional considerations transgender intended parents face, including coordination with gender-affirming care providers when needed.

Your family deserves an agency that doesn’t just tolerate your love story—but celebrates it. The best gay surrogacy agency for your family combines extensive LGBTQ+ experience with the clinical expertise and emotional support needed to make your parenthood dreams a reality.

Ready to Start Your Journey? Contact these leading LGBTQ+-friendly agencies to discuss your family-building goals and find the perfect partner for your surrogacy journey. Every family’s path is unique, but you don’t have to walk it alone.