Choosing a surrogacy agency is a pivotal step in your path to parenthood. More than managing logistics, the right agency provides clarity, emotional support, and reliable guidance through every phase of the process.

With the right information in hand, you can make informed decisions that move you closer to growing your family with confidence.

Connect with a surrogacy professional who aligns with your values and is ready to support your journey from start to finish.

Key Factors to Consider When Choosing a Surrogacy Agency

Understanding what distinguishes one agency from another is key to making a confident, well-informed decision.

A qualified surrogacy agency goes beyond basic coordination—it acts as a trusted advisor and committed partner throughout your entire family-building journey.

Why Your Choice Matters

A surrogacy agency serves as the central coordinator for essential aspects of your journey—from medical evaluations and legal contracts to surrogate matching and emotional guidance.

Selecting a reliable agency ensures that each step is managed with clarity, consistency, and professional care.

This relationship typically spans a year or more, making the agency a key partner in many life-changing milestones.

Agencies with a solid track record, responsive communication, and a strong commitment to client support can significantly improve both your experience and outcomes.

What to Look For

• Proven Track Record and Success Rates: Prioritize agencies with a consistent history of successful matches and positive reviews. Ask for data that reflects their match rates, average timelines, and client satisfaction.
• Transparent Costs and Services: Ensure you receive a comprehensive breakdown of services and associated costs. Agencies should be upfront about all fees and provide clear documentation to avoid unexpected expenses.
• Thorough Screening Standards: Evaluate how the agency screens both intended parents and surrogates. A reputable agency includes medical exams, psychological evaluations, and background checks as standard protocol.
• Compliance and Legal Integrity: Confirm that the agency operates in accordance with your state’s laws and collaborates with licensed attorneys experienced in assisted reproduction law.
• Comprehensive Support Structure: Look for agencies that offer access to dedicated case managers, counseling resources, and regular updates. Continuous communication and emotional support contribute to a smoother and more reassuring experience.

Ask each agency how they address unforeseen challenges such as failed matches, legal complications, or delays. Agencies that demonstrate clear protocols and a commitment to problem-solving are more likely to offer a reliable, stress-reducing partnership.

Compare Surrogacy Agencies: Find the Right Fit for Your Journey

Recognizing how surrogacy agencies vary in their service offerings, wait times, and screening protocols allows you to make a well-informed comparison.

This clarity helps you identify which agency best aligns with your expectations, timeline, and support needs.

What Services Are Included?

Not all agencies offer the same level of support. Some manage every detail—from surrogate recruitment and legal coordination to counseling and insurance assistance.

Others may only provide limited services, requiring you to handle key parts of the process yourself.

Ask for a full, itemized list of what’s included in each agency’s program. Clarify whether services are managed in-house or handled by third-party professionals. Knowing exactly what you’re paying for helps you avoid hidden costs and ensures consistent quality of care.

Wait Times and Matching Expectations

Matching timelines can significantly impact your overall surrogacy experience. Some agencies promise quick matches but pair intended parents with surrogates before completing full screenings—a practice that often leads to complications and delays.

Look for agencies that complete thorough medical, psychological, and background checks before initiating any match. Ask for average wait time data and what factors might shorten or extend your timeline. An honest, well-documented process is a strong sign of an agency’s integrity and efficiency.

How They Screen Surrogates

Surrogate screening should include comprehensive medical testing, psychological evaluations, and criminal background checks. Confirm that all screening is completed before matching occurs.

Also ask if intended parents must update their documentation after a certain time. Keeping everything current helps prevent unexpected delays.

Surrogacy Agency Reviews: How to Check an Agency’s Reputation

A surrogacy agency’s reputation offers valuable insight into how they treat clients, handle challenges, and deliver on promises. To avoid setbacks and build a strong foundation for your journey, take time to evaluate agencies across multiple, trusted sources:

• Google Reviews: Look for consistent, authentic client feedback across locations and timeframes.
• Facebook groups and Reddit forums: Surrogacy-focused communities often share firsthand experiences and name specific agencies.
• Surrogacy directories and advocacy sites: Many feature expert-vetted lists, ratings, and third-party reviews that reflect service standards.
• Personal blogs or video testimonials: Stories from intended parents and surrogates provide emotional context and highlight how agencies handle real-life journeys.

Whenever possible, request direct referrals from agencies. Speaking with past clients offers honest insights into how the agency communicates, problem-solves, and supports families throughout the process.

What to Look For in Reviews

When reading reviews, focus on signals that reflect quality and consistency:

• Repetition of praise or complaints: Pay attention to recurring feedback about communication quality, transparency, support, or delays. Patterns across multiple reviews often highlight the agency’s strengths—or reveal consistent weaknesses that could impact your experience.
• Responsiveness and accessibility: Consistent feedback about timely communication, fast follow-ups, and a dedicated point of contact indicates that the agency values your time and prioritizes client care throughout the process.
• Results and emotional support: Look for reviews that detail successful outcomes, comprehensive legal follow-through, and the availability of ongoing emotional support after the match. These firsthand accounts often reveal whether the agency offers a truly supportive, full-service experience from start to finish.

Also pay close attention to how agencies handle negative feedback. Agencies that respond with clarity, empathy, and a commitment to improvement often demonstrate the kind of accountability and professionalism you’ll want on your journey.

Strong surrogacy agency reviews are more than high ratings—they’re evidence of how consistently and respectfully an agency supports clients through one of life’s most personal milestones.

What Questions to Ask a Surrogacy Agency

Knowing what to ask can help you get the clear, honest answers you need to choose the right agency with confidence. Asking the right questions helps you understand how a surrogacy agency operates and whether it aligns with your needs.

At your initial consultation, bring a well-prepared list to evaluate transparency, reliability, and fit. Consider including these:

Agency Operations and Partnerships:

• Do you work exclusively with certain clinics, or can intended parents choose their own?
• Are legal and psychological services provided in-house, or referred out?

Contingency Planning and Flexibility:

• What happens if a match falls through or the pregnancy does not continue?
• Will you work with intended parents who only have one embryo available?

Screening and Matching:

• What percentage of applicants pass your surrogate screening process?
• How long is the average wait to be matched with a surrogate?

Eligibility and Support Scope:

• Can intended parents without a medical infertility diagnosis still use your services?
• How is surrogate compensation managed, and how is proper insurance coverage ensured?
• What emotional support or counseling resources are available to intended parents and surrogates?

Capacity, Communication, and Differentiators:

• How many cases does your team manage at one time?
• What sets your agency apart from others?
• Will each client have a dedicated case manager or primary point of contact?

A credible agency will offer direct, detailed responses, share relevant documentation, and explain how their services are customized to your specific situation.

If responses are unclear, overly general, or avoid your questions, consider it a warning sign. Leading agencies prioritize transparency, welcome informed questions, and empower you to make decisions with confidence.

Surrogacy Agency Red Flags: What to Watch Out For

Learning to recognize red flags early can help you avoid problems, delays, or stress during your surrogacy journey. Some agencies may not explain things clearly, make promises that sound too good to be true, or offer little support. These are signs that the agency may not be the best fit for your needs.

Lack of Transparency

An agency that cannot provide clear, direct answers about costs, legal procedures, or screening protocols may be disorganized or hiding critical information. Reliable agencies explain their processes thoroughly, offer itemized pricing, and remain consistent in their communication across every stage.

Unrealistic Guarantees

Be wary of agencies that promise guaranteed matches or extremely short wait times without explanation. Surrogacy is a complex, highly individualized process.

Ethical agencies set accurate expectations, communicate potential variables, and offer data-backed estimates based on actual experience.

Inadequate Support Structure

Strong support is essential to a smooth journey. Red flags include the absence of a dedicated case manager, unresponsive staff, or limited access to counseling services.

Also watch for outdated digital presence, missing contact information, or reluctance to provide references—these often signal deeper problems with reliability and client care.

How to Choose a Surrogacy Agency That Aligns With Your Values and Identity

Choosing a surrogacy agency that reflects your values, background, and identity can make your journey smoother, more inclusive, and deeply supportive. The right agency will ensure your experience feels personalized, respectful, and aligned with what matters most to you.

Respect for Your Values

Every family brings distinct values, traditions, and priorities to the surrogacy process. Work with an agency that demonstrates cultural competence, honors diverse belief systems, and offers communication in your preferred language.

Ask how they accommodate various cultural needs and whether they’ve successfully supported families with similar perspectives and expectations.

LGBTQ+ Inclusive Services

If you identify as LGBTQ+, look for agencies with a strong track record of inclusivity. Ask about their experience supporting LGBTQ+ intended parents, whether surrogates are comfortable working with all family types, and if staff receive diversity and inclusion training.

An affirming agency will proactively address legal nuances, emotional support, and family-building goals tailored to your experience.

Region-Specific Expertise

Local laws can affect timelines, contracts, and medical procedures. Partner with an agency that understands the legal landscape in your state and has experience handling cases in your region.

Agencies with local expertise can better manage logistics, provide state-compliant legal support, and connect you with reputable clinics and professionals nearby.

Take the Next Step toward a Supported Surrogacy Journey

Choosing a surrogacy agency is one of the most important decisions on your path to parenthood. You deserve guidance, clarity, and a team that supports your values and vision.

Use this guide to compare agencies, explore surrogacy programs, and take your next step with confidence.

Explore Surrogacy Programs